Surface Area & Shape
You know from the discussion of
Drag Force that frontal
area influences the drag a body experiences in an air
stream. A bicyclist who is standing up in her seat experiences
more drag force because her frontal area is greater
than when she is crouched on the same bicycle in a racing
position. Surface area affects the drag force a parachute
produces.
There are two types of surface area that could be relevant:
the flattened area of the canopy when
it is laid out on a table, and the inflated
area when the parachute is descending. In fact,
with a circular parachute design, the diameter of an
inflated parachute is only about 2/3 that of the canopy
laid out flat. Figuring out ways to keep the parachute
most fully opened when deployed leads some to use a
frame in their designs.
When a parachute falls, you can imagine that it will
interact with a column of air below it. The inflated
area better predicts the drag force because its
size is the effective frontal area, determining how
large a column of air the parachute interacts with by
moving it aside, creating friction with it as it passes,
and making turbulence behind it.
One of the drawbacks of adding more surface area, which
can increase the drag force and help the parachute achieve
a slower terminal speed, is that it usually involves
adding more coffee filters, and thereby more weight.
Spreading out filters so that they overlap less can
increase the chute's surface area without adding to
the mass.
Without regard to size, the 3-D shape of the parachute,
and its orientation, affects the drag coefficient
of the body, which affects the drag force. Studies have
shown that a half-circle or hemisphere, with its open
end facing the flow of air, has the highest drag coefficient
(1.42). If you rotate the cup so that its rounded end
faces the wind, that number drops to 0.38.
Parachute Design Tip: When students
are thinking of whether to orient their coffee filters
so that their openings points upwards or downwards,
they will get more stability when it points up, but
less drag.
The parachute's shape also determines how the direction
and force of airflow as the chute passes by. A flat
canopy will exert less drag than a cupped
canopy (though either will exert far more drag
than the cupped shape facing upward).
Parachute Design Tip: Having a stiff,
flat canopy does not work as well as one that inflates
during descent, which results in more drag force as
the air flow is caught by it.
|